Has your book idea already been done? What authors found
You search your topic and find shelves of books. It is the most common reason people shelve a good idea. Here is how seven authors interviewed on Scribe Media's Author Hour thought about writing into a crowded topic, sorted into four kinds of room they found.
First, a crowded shelf is not bad news
Our guide to comparable titles makes the point from the publishing side: recent books on your subject show that readers pay to solve the problem. An empty shelf is often the bigger warning. What a crowded shelf does demand is an answer to one question: why would my reader want this book as well as, or instead of, the others?
Patrick Donohoe held off for years on exactly this worry:
I’ve been doing this for over our 12th year now and haven’t written a book because I felt that what was needed to be said was said.
What changed his mind, he said, was realizing that his work was about something deeper than a financial concept or product. Experiences with clients led him to an argument about what people are really pursuing, which the existing books did not make. The topic was crowded. His angle on it was not. The four kinds of room below are the angles other authors found.
Room 1: the basics, in order
Some authors do not claim new ideas at all. Michael Lynch, a financial planner, said so directly:
There’s nothing new under the sun believe it or not, they’re just really isn’t. What we want to do is we want to revisit the basics and the basics really are the basics.
His room was not novelty but simplicity: a short book on the basics (he said his first client to read it finished it in about three hours), for people whose financial plans had grown too complicated to follow. Look at his title. The promise is in the first three words. If your field is full of complex books, a clear and ordered treatment of the fundamentals for a specific reader is a real angle, as long as you are honest that the fundamentals are the point.
Room 2: the part people skip
Darius Mirshahzadeh wrote about company core values, a subject with well-known books already on it. He named some of them, said that discovering core values was not a new idea, and said where he thought the gap was:
People actually doing the work because there’s a reason to do it beyond checking a box, their MBA program told them to do, is where I think there’s a lot of room for opportunities.
He said companies often do the exercise, write the values down, and file them away. His book focused on what happens after the discovery: using the values in the business. Many topics have this shape. The first step is well covered; the hard, unglamorous follow-through is not. If your experience is in making something actually work, that may be your book.
Room 3: the playbook nobody wrote
Sometimes the gap is a specific piece of practical guidance. Natalie Dawson had hired and developed teams for many business owners, and saw what was missing:
Nobody has written that playbook, and that is what TeamWork is all about.
The playbook she meant was how business owners can act as coaches to their team members rather than as bosses. Eli Schwartz found the same kind of gap in his field after years of speaking and writing about search engine optimization:
I realized, there wasn’t enough being said about how to build great process around SEO.
His field had plenty written about tactics. What he saw missing was the question executives actually ask: how to organize and build the work at a large company. Note that both authors found the gap through their own work, not by searching for an unclaimed topic. The test is whether the people you serve keep asking for something the existing books do not give them.
Room 4: a reader the other books ignore
Brent Sprenkle wrote about building a real estate portfolio, one of the most written-about subjects in business publishing. He was specific about the book he would not write:
What I didn’t want to do is write a book about how to turn $5 into owning a couple of buildings. That’s been written before
He said he wanted to write for people who already owned a few rental houses or a small building and wanted to understand how others had grown far beyond that. The book drew on his questions to clients who had done it. Same topic, different reader: the person in the middle of the path, whom the beginner books leave behind.
Keith Mitnik did something similar in a narrow industry. His company makes LCD displays, and his book uses that world to explain buyer and supplier relationships. He described his angle carefully:
That’s what I’m trying to articulate here in this book and I don’t think that it’s really been done before in this way.
"In this way" is the honest phrasing. Supplier relationships are not a new subject. His specific approach, learned from twenty years of turning away customers who were not a good fit, was the new part.
The crowded-topic test
Read three to five recent books your reader would also buy, then answer these questions in writing. You need a clear "yes" to at least one.
| Question | If yes, your room is | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Do the existing books make the subject seem harder than it is for my reader? | The basics, in order | Michael Lynch |
| Do they stop at the step where people usually fail? | The part people skip | Darius Mirshahzadeh |
| Do my clients still ask for something none of them provide? | The missing playbook | Natalie Dawson, Eli Schwartz |
| Are they all written for a beginner, or all for an expert? | A reader they ignore | Brent Sprenkle |
| Do I see the subject through an experience few authors have? | A new way in | Keith Mitnik, Patrick Donohoe |
If every answer is no, the honest conclusion is that this book may not need you yet. That is worth knowing before you spend a year on it. Change one thing, usually the reader or the promise, and run the test again. The guide to testing a book idea shows how to check your answer with real readers, and the comparable titles worksheet gives you a page to record what each existing book does and does not do.
The book idea starter asks for three comparable books and checks whether they are recent. Scribe Media makes this site and sells book coaching, ghostwriting and publishing; you can use the starter without talking to anyone.
Common questions
Should I write a book if there are already books on my topic?
Existing books are usually good news: they show people buy books on the subject. The question is whether you have a different reader, a missing piece, a better order or a fresher method. If you cannot name any difference after reading the main books, rethink the angle before you write.
How do I find what is missing in my topic?
Read the recent books your reader would also buy, especially their middling reviews, and listen to the questions your clients still ask after reading them. The gap is usually a step the books skip, a reader they ignore, or advice that no longer works.
Is it a problem if my ideas are not original?
Not necessarily. Several authors on this page said plainly that their core ideas were not new. Their books added order, a specific reader, or the hard part of actually doing the work.
Sources: interviews on Author Hour, the podcast published by Scribe Media, linked beside each quote and checked November 15, 2026. Quotes are exact words from the guest's own answers; summaries in plain text are ours. Published by Scribe Media.