Author stories

Where book titles come from: eleven authors' title stories

Most title advice is a list of formulas. This page is the other half: where real titles actually came from, told by the authors on Scribe Media's Author Hour podcast. Read them for the pattern, then try it on your own book.

A title has two jobs. It has to make the right reader stop, and it has to be true to what is inside. Our guide on choosing a title and subtitle covers the approaches and the rules. The stories below show how those choices felt from the inside, including the false starts. Each is one author's experience, quoted from their interview, not a method that will work the same way for everyone.

From what the reader feels

Jolene Winn had wanted to write a book since middle school. When she finally knew what it was about, she framed it as advice to her younger self, and the first title followed from that.

So initially, I titled my book, To The Girl I Used To Be, almost thinking it was a letter

She came to a title call sure of it. The person helping her asked what her reader would feel when she looked at the book, and that question moved the title from the author to the reader:

she got me thinking more and more about who I was writing for.

Her answer was that the reader feels she is not enough, and the title came from that. She called it the most profound part of writing the book. The lesson is plain: the first title described what the author was doing (writing a letter). The final one named what the reader already felt. If your working title describes your process or your credentials, ask Jolene's question.

From one moment in the author's life

Some titles are a single scene the author could not stop thinking about. Lorenzo Gomez worked in the produce department of a grocery store as a teenager, and his mother told him she had seen his photo on the wall above the cilantro. He was proud and embarrassed at once, and he decided that photo would not be the peak of his career:

If I want my picture on the wall above the cilantro, I want to do something worthy of having it up there.

He said that moment is how he set up the book and where the title came from. Brett Russo's title for Underwear in My Shoe arrived the same way, from a small detail she kept noticing while waiting in doctors' offices (her Author Hour interview). She said The title came to me way before a lot of this was even written, and that she expected women who read it to recognize the moment. Fallon Ukpe found hers in a note she wrote to a family friend's daughter who was graduating from college:

One of the big things that I put in there, and one of the first things I told her is that life is not a straight line up and to the right. I actually drew it in there. I said, it actually looks a bit more like this. I drew a squiggly line.

What these three share: the image is concrete (a photo above the cilantro, a squiggle on a card), and it carries the whole argument of the book. A reader who has never heard of the author can still see the picture.

From something someone said out loud

Justin Batt spent his Saturdays planning activities with his four kids while his wife ran her bridal shop. The name for the habit, and later the book, came from one of the children:

“dad, what are we doing for Daddy’s Saturday?” I just about fell out of my chair because I’m like, “that’s it, that’s the name.”

That reaction, falling out of your chair at a phrase someone else used, is a strong signal. A name the people around the idea already use has been tested in the real world before it reaches a cover. Listen for the words your clients, family or audience use for what you do; they are often better than the ones you would invent.

Marney Andes took her title from words she had heard all her life. Her father farmed, loved basketball, and kept telling her to master the easy shots near the basket before launching long ones:

there’s a reason why I also titled the book the title of the second lesson which is, “Start with the give-me shots,” because I can still see it, I can still hear my dad’s voice

Marney Andes, author of Start with the Give-Me Shots: Eight Homegrown Lessons for Business and Life (Author Hour interview)

Notice that the title is one chapter's lesson, promoted to the cover. The subtitle then explains what kind of book it is. That split, a memorable phrase plus a plain explanation, shows up again and again.

From the idea at the center of the book

Some titles name the book's main idea. Shannon Miles wrote about flexible and remote ways of working, and saw her title as a name for something people were already doing:

We just haven’t named it until now. All I did was put a term on something that men, women have been doing for years.

If readers already live the thing you describe but have no word for it, giving them the word can be the whole title.

Eric Gleacher took the opposite route in time. He did not name the book until the argument was on the page:

I just kept writing and when you know, when the book was finished, I thought I made my case and called it Risk Reward Repeat

He explained that each of the three words stands for a part of the argument: taking risk, rewarding the people who helped you, and encouraging others to repeat the process. A title that summarizes a finished case is easier to write once the case exists, which is a good reason not to agonize over the title before you outline.

The titles they did not use

Almost every author had a title they let go. Tyler Cauble's book on commercial leases nearly had a different name:

we actually almost named the book, “Everything is Negotiable.” We ended up going for open for business because it’s much more business oriented.

Eric Redmond changed course after people reacted to his first choice. In his interview he said the original title I wanted to call it was the $50 trillion opportunity, and that he got a lot of pushback because it sounded too big to believe. The book became Deep Tech.

Rick Scadden went the other way and held his ground. A longer title describing his path from prison to the pulpit was on the table, and he turned it down because the short one did more work:

it leaves it open ended and it draws people in and it's curious, right?

Put those together and you get a fair rule: change the title when the pushback comes from your reader's point of view (it sounds unbelievable, it sounds like the wrong kind of book), and keep it when the objection is only that it is unusual.

Where it came fromExample on this pageThe question to ask yourself
What the reader feelsThe Not Enough WifeWhen my reader picks this up, what are they already feeling?
One vivid momentThe Cilantro Diaries, Life Is A Squiggly LineWhich single scene holds the whole argument?
A phrase said out loudDaddy Saturday, Start with the Give-Me ShotsWhat do the people around this idea already call it?
A name for the central ideaThe Third Option, Risk Reward RepeatWhat are my readers already doing that has no name yet?
Cutting the long versionFour Time FelonWhich two or three words make a stranger curious?

Try it on your own book

  1. Write down the working title, and leave it alone for now. Several of these authors only found the final title after chapters existed.
  2. Answer Jolene's question in your reader's words. If you have not pinned down that reader yet, start with who your book is for.
  3. List the scenes and phrases you repeat. The stories you tell in every talk and the line clients quote back to you are title material.
  4. Generate far more options than feels sensible, ideally with one other person in the room, and notice which one makes them react.
  5. Test the shortlist on people who match your reader, not on friends. Then let the subtitle do the explaining; our subtitle examples show how.

The book idea starter asks for a working title and subtitle next to your reader and promise, so you can see whether they match. Scribe Media makes this site and sells book coaching and publishing; you do not need either to use the starter.

Common questions

Should I pick my book title before I start writing?

You can pick a working title, but the authors on this page show the final one often arrives late. Eric Gleacher named his book only once it was finished. A working title is a label for the project, not a promise you have to keep.

Where do good nonfiction titles usually come from?

In these stories, from four places: what the reader feels, a vivid moment from the author's life, a phrase someone already says out loud, and the central idea of the book. Some came from another person: a child, a parent, or someone who asked a better question.

What if people push back on my title?

Listen to who is pushing back. Eric Redmond changed his after pushback, and Rick Scadden kept his against it. The question to ask is whether your reader would understand it and want to pick the book up, not whether everyone likes it.

Sources: interviews on Author Hour, the podcast published by Scribe Media, linked beside each quote and checked November 15, 2026. Quotes are exact words from the guest's own answers; summaries in plain text are ours. Published by Scribe Media.