Author decisions

One book, two audiences: how authors chose who comes first

You set out to write for one reader and a second one keeps showing up: parents and students, the public and professionals, beginners and veterans. Here are five decisions authors made when that happened, in their own words, and a short test for picking the reader who comes first.

Our guide to defining the one reader argues that a book should be written to one person. That advice holds. But when Author Hour hosts ask Scribe authors who their book is for, many name two or three groups. They are not contradicting the rule so much as describing the order in which readers matter. The decisions below show how they set that order, and where a second audience helped rather than diluted the book.

Decision 1: who gains the most from the whole book?

Adii Pienaar named his primary reader by a simple test:

the primary reader that can probably gain most out of the whole book is an entrepreneur, is a founder, it’s someone that runs their own business

Adii Pienaar, author of Life Profitability: The new measure of entrepreneurial success (Author Hour interview)

He went on to say that anyone ambitious who works in or leads a team could benefit too, because the ideas ripple out from the reader to the people around them. But the founder came first.

"Gains the most from the whole book" is a good working definition of a primary reader. It is not the biggest group or the most prestigious one. It is the one for whom every chapter matters. Other readers can take the chapters that apply to them.

Decision 2: do the groups need the same thing?

Chuck Rylant, a police officer who also teaches at a police academy, wrote about officers involved in shootings. He was open about writing for several readers at once:

Yeah, I had three audiences when I wrote it. The first would be the public, to help them understand just how complicated it is for an officer and how much of a consequence there is to the officer after he pulls the trigger, he or she.

He said the second audience was officers who had been through a shooting and felt alone, and the third was new officers who get no preparation for what happens afterward. Those three groups need different things from the book: understanding, company and preparation. What made one book possible was that the same material, the real stories of what officers went through, served all three. When your groups need different outcomes, check whether the same evidence carries them. If it does, one book can work. If each group needs different content, you may be planning two books.

Marlene Belfort, a scientist, went the other way. She widened her reader on purpose because the need was shared:

the people I most wanted to reach were young people, not exclusively women and not exclusively scientists, because I think the kinds of doubts and fears and imposter feelings are not exclusively ones of scientists.

Her primary reader is still specific: young people at the start of a career who feel insecure, as she did at that stage. What she dropped was a label (women, scientists) that did not change what the reader needed. That is the safe way to widen: define the reader by their situation and feeling, not by a category that does not matter to the book.

Decision 3: who finds it, who uses it?

Sometimes the audiences are not competing. They are steps in a chain. Jeb White wrote a guide to college admissions and watched how it actually moved between readers:

Then they work through the book with their student and there comes some point where they sit down with their school counselor and the school counselor tries to push them back towards the old way of doing things. At that point, the book comes out from a purse or from a backpack and the discussion starts from there.

In his account, the parent usually finds the book first, works through it with the student, and brings it to the counselor. That tells you how to plan. The title and the opening chapter have to win the parent. The working chapters have to be usable by a parent and student together. And the arguments have to hold up in front of a professional who may disagree. If your book will be bought by one person and used by another, map that chain before you outline.

Decision 4: leave room for the reader you did not plan

Jeb White had one more finding. The group that took to the book most was not the one he expected:

school counselors is the audience that seems to be receiving it the most, is that they recognize that they can’t keep up with the evolving trends of the college admissions world and this playbook is a welcome.

You cannot plan for every reader, and you should not try. But you can avoid shutting out the likely second audience. Write so a professional in the field would find the book accurate and current, even if you write it for a beginner. That costs little and keeps the door open for exactly this kind of surprise.

Decision 5: say who it is not for

Angie Noel's book addresses senior leaders, people considering leadership, and anyone feeling disconnected in a leadership role. That is a broad spread. What holds it together is a clear line about who the book is not for:

That’s the first thing we have to say I think is that this is not for everybody. You may have heard it from the time you were in kindergarten. But leadership is not for everybody

Her readers differ in seniority, but they share one question: do I actually want this role? A book can serve several groups when they share the question it answers, and saying plainly who should not read it makes it easier for the right people to recognize themselves. The title does the same job. Our guide to writing your book's promise shows how to put that question at the center.

A test for your own book

List each audience and answer these questions honestly. The reader with the most "yes" answers comes first. If it is a tie, go with your goal: the reader you need to reach for the book to do its job.

QuestionWhy it matters
Does this reader need every chapter?Adii Pienaar's "gain most out of the whole book" test.
Does the same evidence serve them?Chuck Rylant's three readers all needed the same real stories, for different reasons.
Are they the one who finds and buys the book?In Jeb White's account, the parent found it first; the title had to reach the parent.
Can you describe their situation in detail?Marlene Belfort defined her reader by stage and feeling, not by job title.
Do they share the book's central question?Angie Noel's readers all face the question of whether leadership is for them.

Then write a one-line note under your promise: "Also useful for..." That line is where the second audience lives. It can shape a few examples and a section of the book, and it can go in your marketing, but it does not change the promise. If your reader is a younger version of yourself, the guide on writing for your younger self covers the same choice from another side.

The book idea starter checks whether your goal and your reader match, which is often where a two-audience problem shows up first. Scribe Media makes this site and sells book coaching, ghostwriting and publishing; the starter is free.

Common questions

Can a nonfiction book have two target audiences?

Many do. The authors on this page all named more than one group of readers. What helped them was knowing which group the book was built around, and making choices about format, examples and stories that served that group.

How do I choose my primary audience?

Start with the reader your goal depends on, then check two things: which group has the more urgent version of the problem, and which group you can describe in the most detail. If one reader wins on all three, write for them.

Will writing for one audience lose me the other?

Not usually. Secondary readers still read a book that is clearly written for someone else, as long as the examples do not shut them out. Marlene Belfort wrote for young people at the start of their careers, not only for women or scientists, because the feelings she wrote about are shared.

Sources: interviews on Author Hour, the podcast published by Scribe Media, linked beside each quote and checked November 15, 2026. Quotes are exact words from the guest's own answers; summaries in plain text are ours. Published by Scribe Media.