Checklist

What your book is not: lines nine authors drew early

Defining a book means saying what it is. It also means saying what it is not, and that second list is often the more useful one when you plan. Here are eight lines that nine Scribe authors drew around their books, in their own words, as a checklist you can run on your own idea.

Every book idea attracts material: stories, side topics, a second argument, a chapter for a different reader. Without a clear edge, the plan keeps growing and the promise gets vaguer. The authors below, all interviewed on Scribe Media's Author Hour podcast, each named something their book would not be. Some decided before writing. Some found out from a first draft. Use the list as a set of questions, and write your own answer to each before you outline. If you have not yet written your book's promise, do that first; each "not" protects it.

1. Not a memoir, unless it is

The most common blurred line in nonfiction is between telling your story and teaching what you know. Jim Sholler found it in his first draft, when his sister read it:

read the first draft and said, are you writing a memoir or do you want to train people? And I said, no, no, no, it's not a memoir. And she goes, all right, we have to start over.

Starting over on a whole draft is the expensive way to learn this. Ask her question now: am I writing my story, or am I training the reader? Our guide to choosing the kind of book explains what each answer means for the outline.

Your line: My book is not a memoir / not a how-to (pick one), and my own story appears only where it ______.

2. Not the book everyone expects on this topic

Some subjects come with a default book attached. Jared Graybeal wrote a book about personal growth and was clear about which shelf it was not on:

This book is not a 10x book, this book is not get-all-the-money-in-the-world book. This book is about optimizing your life, fulfilling your true potential

Jared Graybeal, author of The Self Help Book: Six Practical Ways to Never Stop Growing (Author Hour interview)

Ben Brennan did the same for a technical subject, and put the signal right on the cover with an unexpected title and image:

we wanted to try to convey that this is not your typical IT manual

If your reader will assume your book is like the others in its category, say early and plainly how it differs. Your comparable titles tell you what the default looks like.

Your line: Readers will expect a book like ______. Mine is not that, because ______.

3. Not a slogan

Books about hard experiences risk sounding cheerful in a way that insults the reader. Erik Weihenmayer, who wrote about adversity, drew this line:

one of the ideas behind No Barriers is it’s not a motivational poster. It’s not like a nice little sound bite.

He said the book starts from the reader being crushed and in a dark place, not from a bright new beginning. If your reader is in real difficulty, decide now that the book will meet them where they are.

Your line: My book will not pretend that ______ is easy.

4. Not a lecture

Paul Hobby wrote about how people get stuck in one-sided conversations and online rabbit holes. The first decision he described was about tone:

Well, the first thing is what I didn't want it to be. I didn't want it to be as a scold.

He wanted the book to be an invitation for readers to look honestly at their own habits, and said that is why he chose a cheerful title. Tone is part of what a book is. Decide it before you write, because a book that scolds is hard to fix with edits.

Your line: My book will sound like ______, not like ______.

5. Not the format you did not choose, and say so honestly

Jeremy Amyotte chose a story-led book over a step-by-step one, and was candid about the trade-off:

To be honest, I don’t think I actually did a great job of explaining that in the book. I did not want the book to be a how-to as much as sort of a philosophical storybook to reframe how you think about things

He pointed readers to other resources for the practical part. That is a fair choice, and his honesty about it is a useful warning: if you rule out the how-to, some readers will still want one. Plan where they will find it.

Your line: My book is mostly ______ (stories / steps / argument). Readers who want ______ will find it in ______.

6. Not dated

Scott A. Martin heard advice from another author about case studies, and weighed it against his goal:

my goal is to make it a foundational, timeless book. I don't want it to be out of date.

He kept the book itself focused on lasting ideas and moved case studies and extra material into a free online area for readers, organized chapter by chapter. Examples that depend on this year's tools or news make a book look old within a few years. Decide which of yours can live outside it.

Your line: Anything that depends on ______ goes in a companion resource, not the book.

7. Not everything you know

Ryan Bisio's book connects basketball and music, a subject with no natural edge. He described how much he left out:

there was a lot left on the cutting room floor with this book, you know, because I really could have flooded the zone and just overwhelmed people with these concepts.

He added that the whole book could have been about one idea, rhythm and tempo, alone. He narrowed it so readers who found the concepts abstract could follow. Experts almost always know more than one book can hold. The question is what this reader needs, in what order, and what can wait.

Your line: These topics are for another book or another format: ______.

8. Not yet

Sometimes the line is about timing. Erik Huberman wrote a full proposal and synopsis for a different book years before his published one, about succeeding without greed, and then shelved it:

And I realized as I finished the whole project that I wasn't successful enough to be preaching that.

He said he also did not like how it turned out. Years later, he wrote instead about the marketing method his company had used throughout its history. The first idea was not wrong. It needed more proof behind it than he had at the time. If your idea depends on a result you have not yet achieved, ask whether a different book, built on what you have already done, should come first.

Your line: I can write this book now because I have already ______.

The checklist on one page

The lineQuestion to answer before you outlineAuthor who drew it
Not a memoir (or not a how-to)Am I telling my story or training the reader?Jim Sholler
Not the default bookWhat will readers assume, and how am I different?Jared Graybeal, Ben Brennan
Not a sloganWhere is my reader really starting from?Erik Weihenmayer
Not a lectureWhat tone will my reader accept?Paul Hobby
Not the other formatWhat have I ruled out, and where can readers get it?Jeremy Amyotte
Not datedWhich examples will age, and where do they go?Scott A. Martin
Not everythingWhat does this reader need, and what can wait?Ryan Bisio
Not yetDo I have the proof this book needs today?Erik Huberman

Keep your answers next to your outline. When a new chapter idea appears halfway through, check it against the list before it goes in. The outlining guide covers how to build the chapter list itself.

The book idea starter puts your reader, promise and chapter list on one page, which makes it easier to spot chapters that do not belong. Scribe Media makes this site and sells book coaching, ghostwriting and publishing; the starter is free.

Common questions

Why decide what my book is not?

Because every idea you could include competes for the same pages. A short list of what the book will not be makes it easier to say no to material that belongs elsewhere, and it tells readers quickly whether the book is for them.

Should the 'not' list go in the book itself?

Often one or two lines do, usually in the introduction or on the back cover, where they help the right reader recognize the book. The rest of the list is a planning tool for you.

What do I do with the ideas I leave out?

Keep them in a separate file. Authors on this page used left-out material in other ways, such as an online area for readers or a later book. Cutting an idea from this book is not the same as throwing it away.

Sources: interviews on Author Hour, the podcast published by Scribe Media, linked beside each quote and checked November 15, 2026. Quotes are exact words from the guest's own answers; summaries in plain text are ours. Published by Scribe Media.